Um, quite a few things really… I’ll get the bad stuff out of the way first.
In reverse order of importance:
Being forced to use SkyDrive and a Live account to upload images to Twitter. Um, OK, I guess.
Live tiles. Marginally more useful than a red dot with a number on, but barely. I like the way the Me tile lets me know that there are messages or mentions, but the hub itself is a poor Twitter client – I see the approach and I can also accept that these tiles make apps irrelevant, but you have to make the tile as fully featured and as useful as a separate app. I find myself looking at the Me tile then opening the relevant app rather than just using the tile. Kinda defeats the object.
The HTC HD7 with Windows Phone 7 seems a bit shy when it comes to wireless networks. It can see them and it tells you you’re connected to them, but then it continues to use your mobile connection. A pain in the arse with data caps and all that. The only way I can force the phone to connect and use the Wi-Fi is to turn Airplane mode on and then connect to the wireless network and turn airplane mode off. I don’t whinge too loudly about this as it could be my equipment and configuration that causes this, still it’s a pain.
The amazing self-bricking phone.
When I first got my HTC HD7 it bricked itself the day after I bought it. The phone buzzed like it would if you were receiving a call and then restarted itself. However, the phone never made it past the HTC splash screen. No matter, this is a new phone and I am an early adopter so this is just to be expected. Phone was replaced in about ten minutes. Excellent service from O2 there. Months passed and the HTC HD7 functioned normally so it really was just a faulty phone. A slow and well spaced series of updates later and I’m on Mango, which is when the trouble begins. In the past month the phone has done a magic self-bricking magic trick about 4 times. I can do a hard reset to get the phone back to life, but naturally I lose all my settings and everything else actually stored not the phone. This raises an interesting question; who’s to blame? Is this a hardware problem or a software one? If I send it back to HTC will they blame Microsoft if HTC blame Microsoft what avenues are open to me? Anyhow now I have a phone I can’t trust and that is the endgame. I need to be available and on top of my email and Twitter all the time, it’s my business not just my pastime. Dare I trust either a replacement HTC HD7 or the Windows Phone 7 operating system again? The fact I’m using an iPhone 3G until I can get to the O2 shop tells you the answer to that one.
The good stuff?
The tiles are good (hypocrite much?) – the live aspect of them I can take or leave but for quick access to your stuff I like them a lot. When I was testing an iPhone 4S recently the first thing I thought was my god these icons are small. Beautifully crisp and sharp and colourful, but small.
The integration of your social networks is excellent, log in to Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn and Google to have all your contacts in one place. Actually very useful and it just works.
IE is fast in Mango and nice to use – not as fast as safari on the 4S, but that’s a brand new phone with a dual-core processor.
Office app integration, I actually did some real work on a file that was urgent, even track changes showed up. Very useful, very powerful.
The Meh stuff?
I was seduced by the larger screen, but in reality it’s not a major factor. Sometimes the larger screen makes things more difficult. It’s just a bit too large to hold comfortably and use in one hand. Nor does it add a great deal to the overall mobile experience. I thought it would, it didn’t. The disadvantages outweigh the advantages and in comparison to the iPhone 4S the larger screen isn’t worth whatever imagined advantage you think it will bring.
Battery life and camera
Both average and again it highlights the problem for disconnected hardware and software manufacturers – the battery life is probably as much to do with Microsoft as it is HTC – the camera is most likely marginally more HTCs fault than Microsoft, but neither come out of it looking great.
Final thoughts
Not sure who I’d blame more, Windows Phone 7 or HTC – I think it’s Microsoft as the self-bricking trick only appeared to be a regular thing after the Mango update. As it stands I think I’ll be buying myself out of my contract in a month or two and following the herd to iOS street.
Final final thoughts
No screenshots. I know that this is an edge case thing, but for the love of god have you seen how many people on Twitter say “hey, look at this cool thing my iPhone app does” with a picture of said cool thing attached? Come on Microsoft do the decent thing and let people share the good stuff your phone does simply. A picture is worth a 1000 words and all that.